I'm reviving this thread as I tried a few products that seemed to quiet the engine noises.
Over on BITOG, upper cylinder lubes get quite a bit of praise, apparantly the ultra clean gas we get now is "dry" and the UCL helps keeps things clean and running smooth.
So far the redline Sl1
http://www.redlineoil.com/product.aspx?pid=80&pcid=12 has been the most impressive, providing slightly better FE and quieting the engine ticking and knocking noises. Also with our little gas tanks, I can get 7maintenance treatments out of one bottle.
The Lucas and Duralube UCL made things quieter, but I did not see any FE improvements. I don't really buy them for the FE anyway, but for the added protection.