Thanks for all the responses guys...
*Haven't towed a trailer yet. The one tank that did include some off-roading was the trip to Atlantic City and stop in the Pine Barrens when it was brand new. That was 20.3 mpg on the first tank.
*Remote start, not much.
*Stealing gas, not likely
*Run down gas stations, No.. Name brand only but they all have supposedly up to 10 % ethanol. And I run regular.
*When pulling away from stop lights(you mean triple tree?), do you notice everyone in your mirrors, Guilty.. I'm not the most reserved driver but I don't take off like a bat out of hell either. I'm usually in the middle of the pack.
*psi, May be a factor
So the story is we decided last minute to go snowboarding and spend the weekend up in Pennsylvania. So we were traveling up I80 with a steady headwind and Thule snowboard racks and the snowboards were upside down (because I thought it would improve mpg's). When the light came on I was traveling 72mph on cruise control and had 15 miles to my destination. I was going uphill when it ran out on me.
Now this happened Sunday evening. We came back Monday night and Tuesday morning the psi warning light came on. I haven't driven it since and haven't remedied the low pressure. but that should be a factor to the mpg's.
When brand new, 17 MPG wasn't uncommon for me.
Mine has about 2000 miles on it so hopefully it will improve. And I'll try the fuel mapping relearn procedures. Thanks