I was in a similar dilemma before buying my Patriot as I was driving my wife's tin-box Toyota Echo sipping 40 mpg with all the safety of a motorcycle! As I looked for something that would seat five, get good mileage, carry kayaks, bicycles, lumber etc and withstand a crash; choices got limited. I had been interested in the Dodge Caliber, and while waiting to see how they would do, I discovered the Jeep Patriot and resolved to not buy anything until I could drive them side-by-side. It was still close, because I like the look of the Caliber, it does get slightly better mileage and a tad sporty. However, having owned a venerable Jeep Cherokee, the Patriot fit like a glove and it was nice to be in a Jeep again. I tried a Scion XB, but for near the same money, the Patriot was much nicer. I must also say I like the CVT the more I drive it, however, it is its reliability I am most concerned with. If they turn out to be good performers, I may end up replacing our Durango with a Caliber when we no longer need to seat 7.