Hitzy, you're absolutely correct in what you say, that HDC is provided by a computerised application of the ABS system, but this is the nub of my argument. If your gearing is not low enough then the engine is not revving when you're in bottom gear. The frequent application of ABS, as happens during HDC, can result in an engine stall. This doesn't really matter too much when rock-crawling because the friction will mean that you either bump-start again instantly or you'll stay stopped, yet safely. On snow or gloopy mud the stall can result in a slide, leaving you having to do several things at once, control the car and get it quickly re-started.
Since HDC was first introduced in Europe the off-road press has regularly featured instances in which it can be thwarted, leaving you in a worse position than if you didn't have it.
I'm certainly not saying that HDC is bad. It isn't. Its absence is one of the things I miss since changing from a Freelander to a Pat. But, without a bit of education and practice it's not, by any means, the "Idiot's Answer to All Problems".
When going down steep rocky trails, like the ones in the photos of British Columbia it makes driving a pleasure; basically all you've got to do is steer. But once you're off that trail and into the squelch then the brains and the feet have just got to take over.
Rocal