Traded my XJ for a Patriot and I love the Patriot for what it is. No offense, but it's not a hardcore wheeler and it will never hit the tough stuff. The difference is more than skin deep. 4.0L I-6, real transfer case and solid axles is what distinguishes the Cherokee from the Liberty and Patriot. Let's enjoy our Jeeps, have fun, and keep reality in perspective.
Do you have the FDI, or FDII? Your point still holds, but the FDII can handle some, "tough stuff."
I think one thing muckingup comparisons between the Cherokee and the Patriot is only a smaller percentage of pats are trail rated, and if you are comparing a cherokee's off road abiity to the Patriot's, then it only fair to compare the trai-rated/off-road version.
I like the FDI, but those that don't have an FDII, don't have a good idea when it comes to a comparison with the Cherokee. The FDI is not the FDII, and there are significant differences off-road.
There are pluses and minuses to both, the independent suspension on the patriot gives it a better ride, both on and off road, the solid axles are an across the board plus by any means, IMO opinion it gives it more agility off-road. The the low "gear," on the FDII is very adequate. Okay you have more power in the cherokee and more torque, undeniable. The FDII does have BLD, and lots of other electronic toys that are effective and get the job done very well. The patriot is way safer when it comes to breaking your neck than the cherokee. There is absolutely no head room in the cherokee and I have on more than one occassion hit my head on the roof in the cherokee especially when riding in the back seat.
What I am most envious about with the cherokee, is the bumpers, it has small, practical bumpers, instead of the big bulbous plastic ones we get with the patriot.